Tomato Brown Rugose Fruit Virus Federal Import Order FAQs

Last Modified: June 17, 2024

The ToBRFV Import Federal Order applies to imports of tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) and pepper (Capsicum spp.) seed lots, including small lots of seeds, and transplants from all countries.

The Import Federal Order has been in effect since November 22, 2019. APHIS revised the Federal Order June 17,  2024 to remove import requirements for tomato and/or pepper fruit while continuing import requirements unchanged for propagative material. When new scientific information or interceptions of ToBRFV require a modification to import requirements for tomato and/or pepper propagative material, APHIS may modify the Federal Order and notify stakeholders.

Frequently Asked Questions

Importing Tomato and Pepper Propagative Material

Shipments of tomato or pepper seeds or propagative plant materials (including plants for planting, seeds, obscured seed, and cuttings) from all countries must be accompanied by a phytosanitary certificate or a re-export phytosanitary certificate with an additional declaration certifying that the lots fulfill the following requirements prior to importation into the United States and territories:

  • The Solanum lycopersicum and/or Capsicum spp. plants for planting or seeds originated from a country certified free from Tomato brown rugose fruit virus, as established by the national plant protection organizations of that country;

OR

A representative sample of the Solanum lycopersicum and/or Capsicum spp. plants for planting or seed lot has been officially tested and found free of Tomato brown rugose fruit virus.

Shipments of tomato or pepper seeds or propagative plant material without the required documentation will be refused entry into the United States. Shipments that left the exporting country before the publication of the Import Federal Order will be evaluated upon arrival in the United States and samples may be taken to ensure they are free of the virus.

Small lots of tomato and pepper seed originating from a single mother plant or a single breeder line intended for breeding purposes and not for immediate commercial sale may be imported from all countries with a phytosanitary certificate with the following additional declaration:

  • All mother plants of Solanum lycopersicum and/or Capsicum spp. from which the seed lot originated have been officially tested no more than 10 days prior to fruit harvest and found free of Tomato brown rugose fruit virus.

APHIS defines small lots of seed as a maximum of 50 seeds of 1 taxon (such as a genus, species, or cultivar) per seed packet or a maximum weight not to exceed 10 grams of seed of 1 taxon per seed packet. There may be a maximum of 50 seed packets per shipment.

Small lots may also be imported under a PPQ-588 Controlled Import Permit. For more information, see APHIS’ How To Import Plants and Plant Products into the United States web page.  

No, a phytosanitary certificate is required. This Import Federal Order imposes new regulatory requirements on all tomato and pepper propagative material, including plants grown in approved GCP facilities.

APHIS requires an official phytosanitary certificate issued by the National Plant Protection Organization (NPPO) of the exporting country. The certificate must include a statement indicating the materials are free from ToBRFV, as stated in the Import Federal Order. APHIS will not accept third party laboratory testing for ToBRFV in lieu of a phytosanitary certificate with the required statement from the exporting country. Please contact the NPPO of the exporting country to determine their requirements for issuing the phytosanitary certificate with the required statement.

Commercial consignments of tomato and/or pepper seeds do not need a permit. They must be accompanied by an official phytosanitary certificate with the required statement issued by the exporting country’s NPPO, as stated in the Import Federal Order.

No, a phytosanitary certificate is required. This Import Federal Order imposes new regulatory requirements on all tomato and pepper seed. However, a Seed Analysis Certificate or Seed Export Label may still be required to certify the seed lot has been sampled for Federal Noxious Weed seeds according to the U.S. Federal Seeds Act (FSA, 7 CFR 319.61).

"Representative sample" will be determined by the NPPO and will be based on the testing method used.

As noted elsewhere, the National Plant Protection Organization (NPPO) of the exporting country must determine how they wish to satisfy the testing requirement for the phytosanitary certificate. APHIS has evaluated or is evaluating several PCR-based protocols to detect ToBRFV in seeds. In our lab and other laboratories, these protocols have successfully detected ToBRFV in seeds.

Primers / Reference
 
Comment
 
  
ToBRFV-F, 5’-GAAGTCCCGATGTCTGTAAGG-3’
ToBRFV-R, 5’-GTGCCTACGGATGTGTATGA-3’

Reference:
K.S. Ling, et al. 2019 First Report of Tomato brown rugose fruit virus infecting greenhouse tomato in the U.S. and Mexico.
https://doi.org/10.1094/PDIS-11-18-1959-PDN
APHIS has evaluated this protocol (end-point RT-PCR) and has used it successfully for virus detection in seeds, plant and fruit samples. PCR product size: 842bp. Product can be used for direct sequencing for confirmatory diagnostics.
 
ToBRFV-F 5’-AATGTCCATGTTTGTTACGCC-3’
ToBRFV-R 5’-CGAATGTGATTTAAAACTGTGAAT-3’

Reference:
Alkowni, A., et al. 2019. Molecular identification of tomato brown rugose fruit virus in tomato in Palestine. Journal of Plant Pathology.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s42161-019-00240-7

 
Upon further evaluation, PPQ has determined that this RT-PCR is less sensitive than coat protein (CP) gene based assays. Therefore APHIS is not recommending this protocol for ToBRFV detection.
 
CaTa28 Fw 5' -GGTGGTGTCAGTGTCTGTTT- 3'
CaTa28 Pr 5' 6FAM -AGAGAATGGAGAGAGCGGACGAGG- BHQ1 3'
CaTa28 Rv 5' -GCGTCCTTGGTAGTGATGTT -3'

Reference:
ISHI-Veg 2019. Detection of Infectious Tomato brown rugose fruit virus (ToBRFV) in Tomato and Pepper Seed.
https://www.worldseed.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Tomato-ToBRFV_2019.09.pdf
APHIS is currently evaluating this protocol.
 
CSPtbrfv101 Fw 5' - CATTTGAAAGTGCATCCGGTT T - 3'
CSPtbrfv101 Pr 5' VIC -ATGGTCCTCTGCACCTGCATCTTGAGA - BHQ1 3'
CSPtbrfv101 Rv 5' - GTACCACGTGTGTTTGCAGAC A - 3'

Reference:
ISHI-Veg 2019. Detection of Infectious Tomato brown rugose fruit virus (ToBRFV) in Tomato and Pepper Seed.
https://www.worldseed.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Tomato-ToBRFV_2019.09.pdf
APHIS is currently evaluating this protocol.

The country where the seed is located will need to issue a re-export certificate with the required additional declaration after testing the propagative material.

Tomato or pepper seed imported for diagnostic purposes require a PPQ-526 permit “Application and Permit to Move Live Plant Pests or Noxious Weeds.” A phytosanitary certificate is not required for seed imported under a PPQ-526 permit. For more information, see APHIS’ Organism and Pest Permits Page.

Shipments of tomato or pepper seeds imported for research, developmental, or therapeutic purposes (for example, seeds imported for germination tests or variety trials) require a PPQ-588 Controlled Import Permit. A phytosanitary certificate is not required for seed imported under a PPQ-588 permit. For more information, see APHIS’ How to Import Plant and Plant Products web page.

Yes, you can continue to use “PPQ 587 Obscured Seed Permit” to import obscured tomato or pepper seed. However, you must still fulfill the requirements outlined in the Import Federal Order by accompanying the permit with a phytosanitary certificate that includes an additional declaration as stated in the Import Federal Order.

No. Shipments must be accompanied by a phytosanitary certificate that includes the required statement upon arrival at the port of entry.

To avoid potential delays and/or refusal, APHIS recommends that tomato or pepper seed shipments are separated from other species of seeds.

General Information about ToBRFV

ToBRFV can cause severe fruit loss in tomatoes and peppers. On pepper, it causes bubbling and mosaic patterns on leaves, while on tomato foliage it causes mosaic patterns and a “fern leaf” symptom. Infected fruits of both hosts are smaller, discolored, and may have rough, dead patches on the surface (see photos). Infected tomato fruits can be unmarketable or reduced in quality. Necrosis can occur on susceptible pepper fruit.

yellowing of leaf veins, yellow spots and brown rugose symptoms
(Figures 1 and 2: Luria, et al., 2017 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0170429.g001); Figure 3: Alkowni, et al., 2019 https://www.researchgate.net/publication/330722102)

ToBRFV is transmitted through infected propagative plant parts (seeds, plants for planting, grafts, and cuttings), and spreads locally by contact (direct plant to plant contact, contaminated tools, hands, or clothing). ToBRFV can remain viable in seeds, plants debris and contaminated soil for months.

No, ToBRFV does not pose a health risk to people or animals.

ToBRFV-infected fruit is safe to eat. However, if you discard the fruit, throw it in the garbage. Do not put suspicious fruit in your backyard compost pile as seeds in the fruit could sprout into an infected plant.