APHIS verifies compliance with the conditions contained in permits and notifications by inspecting fields, records and associated facilities. Inspections may be done in person or virtually; virtual inspections are referred to as Monitoring and Evaluation Interviews (MEIs). The BRS Compliance Assurance Branches (CABs) initiate and manage inspections. Trained inspectors (from BRS, APHIS’ Plant Protection and Quarantine (PPQ) program, or a participating state inspection program), conduct inspections on behalf of APHIS BRS. Methods of verification used for inspection include: records review, interview, observation, and measurement and mapping.
BRS determines the frequency and number of field test site inspections by assessing the relative risk of each type of trial and by other criteria described below. BRS conducts least one inspection for every permit resulting in a planted field trial and conducts a statistically-valid, random sampling of inspections of plantings that occur under notification—which represent the types of crops with which BRS has the greatest familiarity.
Most persons authorized to engage in regulated activities have a successful history of compliance with APHIS regulations. From time-to-time, a noncompliance incident may occur. Noncompliance incidents can include failing to notify APHIS in the event of an unauthorized release, failing to follow permit conditions (such as isolation distances or volunteer monitoring requirements), and planting at a field test site before an authorization becomes effective or after it expires. When noncompliance occurs, BRS assesses the nature and seriousness of the noncompliance and determines appropriate steps to follow up, ranging from issuing regulatory correspondence to requesting an investigation and seeking sanctions for alleged noncompliance.
Permits require responsible persons to follow procedures described in their applications, the design protocols (e.g., standard operating procedures) they have submitted, and the standard permit conditions and supplemental permit conditions assigned by BRS. BRS ensures compliance with its permit requirements by performing thorough inspections. All permits receive at least one inspection within each authorized state where a field test site is planted each year. Plants engineered to produce pharmaceutical or industrial proteins are inspected up to seven times before, during, and after the planting occurs to verify compliance with permit conditions. These inspections are performed at critical times during field testing, including pre-release, release, reproductive control, harvest, post-harvest and two volunteer monitoring inspections. BRS tracks inspection-related information to assure that all required inspections are accomplished.
After every inspection, inspectors prepare a detailed inspection report. BRS then issues feedback correspondence to the responsible person based on findings documented in the inspection report. The correspondence typically falls into one of the following categories:
BRS also uses these and other letters to communicate findings not specifically related to inspections, such as noncompliance for late submittal of required reports.
Notification inspections are selected based on a statistically valid random sampling method using a computer model that incorporates information from planting reports. Inspectors who conduct inspections use instructions and worksheets to record their observations during inspections. Items on the worksheets correspond with the performance standards described in the applicable regulations. Responsible persons also submit design protocols specifying what methods will be used to meet the performance standards. BRS expects regulated entities to comply with all design protocols and the performance standards, which may include observing isolation distances, confinement measures, harvesting procedures, and devitalization and disposal. The instructions also specify what an inspector must assess to determine compliance with the performance standards. BRS’ written guidance, along with training provided by BRS, contribute to the uniformity of inspection procedures among inspectors.
APHIS requires responsible persons to submit certain reports and notices under the regulations and as part of the requirements of the authorization. Reports and notices provide compliance-related information about regulated materials. Each report and/or notice is associated with a specific permit or notification, and has requirements for due dates and information. BRS uses reports and notices for initiating inspection processes and verifying the status of the authorization and any actions taken under it, such as planting and volunteer monitoring. A report has information on activities that already happened, and a notice contains information on planned activities that will occur in the future.
|Pharma-Industrial Permit (perennial)||Non-random||2 in-season inspections of each site the year of planting, at least one each subsequent year||1 inspections the following growing season, 1 the next growing season**|
|Pharma-Industrial Permit (annual)||Non-random||5 in-season inspections of each site in each state where planted||2 inspections the following growing season|
|Permit (perennial)||Non-random||At least one site inspected in each state where growing each year||Post-harvest inspections as needed|
|Permit (annual)||Non-random||At least one site inspected in each state where planted||Higher frequency for large-scale trials|
|Notification||Randomly selected by computer model||If selected, at least one site inspected in one state*||As needed*|