Questions and Answers About the Plant Protection
Act
Plant Protections and Quarantine
June 2002
Q: What is the Plant Protection Act?
A: The Plant Protection Act (PPA) became law in June 2000
as part of the Agricultural Risk Protection Act. This law consolidates
all or part of 10 existing U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) plant
health laws into one comprehensive law, including the authority to regulate
plants, plant products, certain biological control organisms, noxious
weeds, and plant pests.
The PPA gives the Secretary of Agriculture, and through delegated authority,
USDA's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS), the ability
to prohibit or restrict the importation, exportation, and the interstate
movement of plants, plant products, certain biological control organisms,
noxious weeds, and plant pests.
Under the PPA, violators face harsher civil penalties than ever before
for smuggling illegal plants or produce that could harbor plant pests
or diseases. The PPA gives the Secretary of Agriculture
the authority to subpoena documentary evidence and witnesses to prosecute
violators. The Act also provides APHIS with a cost recovery mechanism
for expenses related to the disposal of abandoned shipments at U.S.
ports of entry.
Q: How does the PPA impact APHIS' regulatory authority?
A: The PPA grants significant new regulatory authority
for controlling noxious weeds and clarifies APHISí existing regulatory
authority for beneficial organisms used in biocontrol.
Q: What are the PPA's specific directives?
A: The PPA specifically directs APHIS to publish a public notice
describing procedures and standards for import requests and to conduct
a study outlining the role and application of systems approaches designed
to guard against the introduction of plant pathogens into the United
States. Systems approaches are a series of overlapping measures
that are applied to agricultural imports. These measures are designed
to mitigate the risk of plant pests or diseases entering the United
States and may include specific treatments, inspections, or certifications.
Q: How is APHIS incorporating new PPA authorities into
regulatory activities?
A: Currently, APHISí Plant Protection and Quarantine
(PPQ) program is developing plans and procedures to incorporate new
PPA authorities. PPQ has identified eight PPA action areas and
established implementation time frames to ensure new authorities are
fully incorporated into program activities. These action areas
include:
1. Publishing a public notice describing procedures and standards
for import requests;
2. Conducting a study outlining the role and application of systems
approaches associated with proposals to import plants and plant products;
3. Establishing uniform procedures for conducting warrantless
inspections;
4. Developing guidelines for the issuance of subpoenas;
5. Creating guidelines for the standardization of civil penalties
to be applied consistently nationwide for specific violations;
6. Establishing internal procedures for cost recovery of expenses
related to the disposal of smuggled or illegal agricultural products
that are abandoned after APHIS takes regulatory action;
7. Soliciting public comment on a concept paper at regional public
meetings prior to the publication of a proposed rule for noxious weeds;
and
8. Developing regulations for the movement of biological control
organisms.
Q: What are the PPAís harsher civil penalties for the
smuggling of illegal agricultural products?
A: The PPA increases civil penalties to a maximum of
$50,000 for any individual who violates the law. However, the maximum
of $1,000 remains for first-time offenders carrying an agricultural
product through ports of entry for personal use only. Any business
or group violating the PPA can now be fined a maximum of $250,000 and
no more than $500,000 per adjudication.
Under the PPA, anyone causing harm to or interfering with an animal
used in official inspections, such as one of the animals in USDA's Beagle
Brigade, can be fined up to $10,000. The Beagle Brigade is made
up of detector dogs that work at international airports and borders
to sniff passenger luggage and packages for hidden fruits, vegetables,
meats, and other agricultural products that may contain invasive animal
or plant pests or diseases.
PPQ is currently developing uniform standards for the enforcement of
these new civil penalties.
Q: When will APHIS use its subpoena power?
A: When an APHIS inspection leads to suspicion
that possible prohibited materials are being housed in a facility, a
thorough investigation will begin. APHIS will request a subpoena
based on an active investigation, evidence that previous attempts to
gain access to documents has been refused, and a reasonable request
for documents pertaining to the investigation. The subpoena will
set a date and time for APHIS to obtain the documents or for a person
to provide testimony at a hearing.
A notice regarding APHIS' subpoena authority and procedures will be
published in the Federal Register in the near future.
Q: Can APHIS conduct inspections without a warrant?
A: Yes. Currently, APHIS conducts these types of inspections
on passenger luggage and cargo every day at all U.S. international airports
and most border crossings. APHIS inspectors look for prohibited
agricultural products that could harm American agriculture by bringing
in plant pests and diseases.
Under the PPA, APHIS also has the authority to conduct inspections
without warrants on interstate commerce, based on probable cause, as
well as intrastate commerce as part of an extraordinary emergency.
A working group of PPQ staffs and APHISí Investigative and Enforcement
Services, with advice from USDA's Office of General Counsel, is developing
written guidelines for warrantless inspections. These guidelines
will follow the U.S. Attorney Generalís guidelines for warrantless
inspections and will include search criteria and procedures that ensure
that warrantless inspections do not violate the legal or constitutional
rights of citizens.
Q: What are the PPA's new cost recovery measures?
A: Previously, when APHIS required regulatory action
for infested or prohibited agricultural products and the importer abandoned
the shipment, APHIS covered the cost of disposing of the cargo.
With the PPA, if the importer fails to take the required remedial measures,
APHIS will take the necessary action and bill the importer for all associated
costs.
Q: What are the PPA's new quality assurance measures?
A: The Act allows APHIS-PPQ to work with industry and other
cooperators to establish programs to improve the health and pest and
disease-free status of specific commodities. One outcome of this
cooperation would be that APHIS can publish industry-developed standards
under its regulatory authority. If industry members wish to voluntarily
comply with these best practices or higher standards, APHIS can authorize
them to put a predetermined quality sticker or seal on their product.
Q: What is APHIS' expanded authority on noxious weeds?
A: The PPA expands the definition of noxious weed from
the definition in the Federal Noxious Weed Act, which included only
weeds that were of foreign origin, new to, or not widely prevalent,
in the United States. The PPA defines a noxious weed
as a weed that could bring harm to agriculture, the public health, navigation,
irrigation, natural resources, or the environment. Under the PPA,
regulations for noxious weeds are similar to those for plant pests.
Under the PPA, the Secretary of Agriculture and APHIS will have the
authority for the first time to declare an extraordinary emergency when
a newly introduced or not widely prevalent noxious weed poses a significant
threat and to declare an emergency that would enable the transfer of
money from other agencies or corporations of the Department, including
the Commodity Credit Corporation, to cover the cost of eradicating the
weed. An extraordinary emergency declaration gives APHIS the authority
to hold, seize, quarantine, treat, or destroy any plant or plant product
being moved within a State that is believed to be infested with a plant
pest or noxious weed. This authority is used when a State is unable
to take the necessary measures itself.
The PPA allows the Secretary of Agriculture to develop a classification
system to describe the status and action level for a specific noxious
weed. In conjunction with the classification system, the Secretary
may develop integrated management plans for noxious weeds for the specific
geographic region or ecological range where the noxious weed is found
in the United States.
A list of noxious weeds that are prohibited from entering the United
States or moving among States, except under a permit with restricted
conditions, is currently available on the APHIS website at www.aphis.usda.gov.
Any person may petition the Secretary of Agriculture to add or remove
a plant species from this list.
Currently, PPQ is developing a concept paper on noxious weeds, which
will be presented at public meetings in Spring 2001. At the conclusion
of the public meetings, PPQ will draft a proposed rule on noxious weeds
for the Federal Register.
Q: How does the PPA impact biological control?
A: The PPA separates biological control organisms, which
were formerly grouped with plant pests, and defines them as any enemy,
antagonist, or competitor used to control plant pests or noxious weeds.
This recognizes that not all organisms in need of permits are plant
pests and that some are actually beneficial to U.S. agriculture and
the environment.
APHIS has developed proposed new regulations for the movement of plant
pests and release of biological control agents of weeds, which should
be published in the Federal Register in the near future.
The PPA reaffirms APHIS authority to regulate biological control to
prevent the introduction or dissemination of plant pests or noxious
weeds and encourages the USDA, other Federal agencies, and the States
to facilitate biological control whenever feasible. The Act also
provides APHIS with guidance on how to regulate the movement of biological
control organisms and authorizes APHISí participation in activities
that enable the effective transfer of biological control techniques.
The PPA broadens the scope of APHISí authority and clarifies
existing authorities to enable APHIS to continue its mission of protecting
Americaís plants and animals. For more information on the
PPA, or to read the Act in its entirety, please visit the APHIS website
at www.aphis.usda.gov.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) prohibits discrimination in
all its programs and activities on the basis of race, color, national
origin, gender, religion, age, disability, political beliefs, sexual
orientation, or marital or family status. (Not all prohibited bases
apply to all programs.) Persons with disabilities who require alternative
means for communication of program information (Braille, large print,
audiotape, etc.) should contact USDA's TARGET Center at (202) 720-2600
(voice and TDD).
To file a complaint of discrimination, write USDA, Director, Office
of Civil Rights, Room 326-W, Whitten Building, 14th and Independence
Avenue, SW, Washington, DC 20250-9410 or call (202)720-5964 (voice and
TDD). USDA is an equal opportunity provider and employer.
Click here for printable version (PDF)
|